English as a Foreign Language (EFL) instruction has always been a topic of debate among teachers, researchers and language experts. One of the main areas of discussion is the teaching of grammar. There are different approaches to teaching grammar and some teachers prefer explicit grammar instruction while others prefer implicit grammar instruction. In this article, we will discuss some advantages and disadvantages of explicit grammar instruction in EFL teaching.
Explicit grammar instruction refers to the direct teaching of grammar rules and structures. It is a teacher-centered approach that focuses on the explicit teaching of grammar rules, and the students’ learning process is usually through memorization and application of the rules. This approach is often used in language schools and language classes that are intended to prepare students for exams or standardized tests.
You might be interested in this related article An introduction to Teacher-Centered and Student-Centered learning
Advantages of explicit grammar instruction
Clarity and structure
One of the main advantages of explicit grammar instruction is that it provides clarity and structure to students. It helps students understand the grammar rules of the language and how to apply them in different situations. Students have a clear understanding of what is expected of them and can improve their language skills with the help of explicit grammar instruction.
Preparation for exams and standardized tests
Explicit grammar instruction is often used to prepare students for exams and standardized tests. It is a great way to ensure that students have a strong understanding of grammar rules, which is often a major component of exams. This approach can help students perform well on exams and achieve higher scores.
Better language skills
Explicit grammar instruction can help students improve their language skills and achieve mastery of grammar rules. It allows students to focus on specific grammar rules and improve their accuracy in using them. This approach can lead to a better understanding of the language and improved language skills.
Development of critical thinking skills
Explicit grammar instruction can also help students develop their critical thinking skills. This is because students are required to analyze the grammar rules, understand their meaning and apply them in different situations. This can help students develop a deeper understanding of the language and improve their critical thinking skills.
Disadvantages of explicit grammar instruction
Over-reliance on memorization
One of the main disadvantages of explicit grammar instruction is that it can lead to an over-reliance on memorization. Students may learn grammar rules by heart, but they may not be able to apply them in real-life situations. This can result in a lack of fluency and accuracy in the language.
Lack of context
Explicit grammar instruction often lacks context. This means that students may not understand the meaning of grammar rules and how to apply them in real-life situations. This can lead to a lack of understanding of the language and a limited ability to use it effectively.
Boredom
Another disadvantage of explicit grammar instruction is that it can be boring for students. This is because it focuses on the explicit teaching of grammar rules and the students’ learning process is often through memorization. This can result in students losing interest in the language and not enjoying the learning process.
Limited creativity
Explicit grammar instruction can also limit creativity in students. This is because students are taught to follow specific grammar rules and may not have the opportunity to express themselves in a creative way. This can result in students not having the ability to use the language creatively and express themselves in a unique way.
In conclusion, explicit grammar instruction has its advantages and disadvantages in EFL teaching. It provides clarity and structure to students, helps prepare them for exams and standardized tests, and can improve language skills and critical thinking skills. However, it can also lead to an over-reliance on memorization, lack of context
